First Level Leadership

How Relevant Are Motivation Theories

The Limitations Motivation Theories

Motivation is a complex phenomenon

I know you are concerned with understanding the strengths and directions of human motivation to increase your control over the performance of work related behaviors. However, motivation is complicated and is dependent on many factors.

It is difficult for theories to offer any simple predictive application in management practice. However, they do provide a stable framework and a starting point.

To enhance your understanding,

let us try to analyze some of the limitations of these theories:

1. They are restrictive and don’t consider the broader concerns influencing people in organizations.

2. The models of motivation are narrow. It places the responsibility for actions on individuals rather than the context in which they find themselves.

3. These theories are unable to explain poor quality, low productivity, and high absenteeism.

4. The recession reduces job mobility as workers stay on rather than take risk by changing job. There could be a high correlation between employment stability and dissatisfaction.

5. Research has tended to focus on motivation of lower grade workers rather than management.

6. The meaning people attach to work varies considerably and may account for why individuals’ contributions to work vary enormously.

7. The theories and approaches to motivation have a homogeneous view of individuals. However, people’s motivation and attitude to work are influenced by age, sex, income, job type and differences in organizational structures.

8. Managers need to discover how motivation varies in different cultures.

The reason for sharing these limitations is to make you aware of the different influences on motivation of individuals.

Are motivation theories relevant for management practice?

That is a highly debatable topic. However, one thing is certain - that they cannot be ignored. Think of practical examples where motivation has been an issue.

Can you apply these theories in diagnosing motivational problems?

Next Step: Sign Up for the First Level Leadership E-zine and get access to good information without any fluff!